Smoke & Mirrors

Hari OM

'Text-days' are for delving into the words and theory of Advaita Vedanta.

TATTVABODHAH.

[You are reminded that reviewing the previous week's posts will become essential as the meanings of the Sanskrit terms may not be repeated. There may come additional or alternative meanings, but all should be noted. As study progresses, the technical terms must necessarily become 'second nature' to the student. When the Sanskrit is used, the translation will fall easily into place - or likewise, if the English is used, the Sanskrit term must easily come forwards.]

Please revisit THIS post and chant the mangala-charana. Please use the TattvabodaH label to access all posts relevant to this text.

MAYA.

Last week we saw the introduction to this section on the brahmaanda - the macrocosm, as in the greater world. We found that when we speak of सृष्टि /srishti (creation), we refer to twenty-four factors in the process; establishing that there is a twenty-fifth, but that being of the nature of  avidya and therefore without beginning, we have to consider it as part of the cause and not of srishti itself. Avidya is the ignorance as it pertains to the microcosm. When we talk of avidya in reference to the macrocosm, it is called as Maya.

The chanting provided here is for the aphorism relating to last week's post and then for today's topic.

अथ च्तुर्विंशति-तत्त्वोत्प्त्तिप्रकारं वक्ष्यामः।

atha chturviMshati-tattvotpttiprakaaraM vaxyaamaH.

"Now we shall explain the evolution of the twenty-four factors."

ब्रह्माश्रया सत्त्वरजस्तमोगुणात्मिका माया अस्ति।

brahmaashrayaa sattvarajastamoguNaatmikaa maayaa asti.

"Depending on Brahman, Maya exists, which is of the nature of the three qualities of sattva, rajas and tamas."

The Truth is, in the macrocosm, referred to as Brahman. Big. This is an adjective which generally qualifies a noun and is limited by the noun it is qualifying. For example, we may say that an elephant is big we immediately envisage the limitation of that 'bigness'. It may be big in relation to other things, but actually can be quite small in relation to the forest it is in. If there is no noun to which the Big adjective is applied, then that Bigness is unlimited, there is no restriction on what that Bigness is and thus it becomes potentially infinite. As we have established that Pure Self is the infinite substratum to everything, and as Brahman is here the Self conditioned by macrocosm, then Brahman and Self must be one and the same thing. Pure, unchanging Reality.

Think carefully now. If we are seeing shristi ( a created cosmos), it would naturally be our thought that Brahman is the creator. However, as everything must arise from something else, it involves an element change, does it not? Yet we have said that Brahman is unchanging. The created cannot come from the uncreated, the Ever-Existing Self. The created can only come from the created… but at some point of time, logically and philosophically, we have to find as we research ever backwards (or inwards…), that we reach to that uncreated entity, the source of everything. We intrinsically understand creation only from the point of the created, but Existence itself cannot be created or modified. Then we hit the question, 'can we say that entire shristhi has arisen from That?' Brahman must have created; this would suggest that until the point of creation, Brahman was quiet for some time and then became active to create. This implies modification. If we accept modification we also have to accept finitude - that is to say, destruction. If we accept that all which is subject to change is also subject to destruction then we now face the incidence of Brahman being destructible. [This can seem very esoteric if you are knew to this type of thinking… go with the flow; it comes up often!]

For there to be a stablising force behind everything, logically we cannot have a destructible Brahman. How can an ever-changing srishti have come from an unchanging cause? Our difficulty remains for as long as we consider that the creative process resembles that of the potter and his lump of clay, removing parts of the big lump to produce an endless variety of smaller clay items.

Vedanta postulates that the srishti element is actually within Brahman. Be careful here and be sure to understand the subtle difference. The creative instance according to Vedanta is not that of larger parts being cut into smaller parts, but of that large part going through internal process; it is a whole item, it transforms itself within itself, remaining forever whole. The 'formula' given is या मा सा माया /yaa maa saa maayaa - that which is not, yet appears to be, is called Maya. From the standpoint of Truth/Brahman/Self, there is no world - yet we experience it. This is Maya. Maya is sometimes referred to as प्रकृति /prkRiti - 'Mother Nature', the creatrix. The traditional example given for this is that of the snake appearing on the rope. The rope (Truth) cannot create the snake yet we experience the snake. As far as the rope is concerned there never was snake and never could be. This is the effect of Maya.

Maya has two powers;

1. आवरण शक्ति  /aavarana shakti - the veiling power; this is of the nature of ignorance. For as long as we are ignorant, we do not know Truth. Aavarana cannot of itself create the world.

2. विक्षेप शक्ति /vikshepa shakti - the projecting power; this is the creative power which projects the entire world of names and forms. It manifests our inherent impressions, but it cannot do this without the help of aavarana - as in the snake rope; the ignorance of the rope should precede the projection of the snake vision.

It is the existence of Maya upon Truth which together give us the creator 'God' - Iishvara. The power of Maya is unfathomable, it can make the impossible seem real. Maya alone creates the boundary-less cosmos from beginningless time and will do so apparently endlessly. Maya at no time is separate from the Truth - it only exists because of that True Existence. Truth itself is not affected by Maya and even is unaware of it. Upon the discovery of Truth, Maya is destroyed, just as finding that the rope is there, the snake dissipates completely.

Now, the aphorism told us also that Maya is of the triguna by nature. Sattva guna is characterised by knowledge, rajo-guna by activity and tamo-guna by inertia. These three qualities pervade the entire srishti and it is by the combination and permutation of the three which brings about the enormous variety we perceive.

Further important points at this stage now, are that there are two causes for any object; the material cause (उपादान कारण /upaadaana kaarana) and the efficient cause (निमित्त कारण /nimitta kaarana).  The clay is the material cause of the pot and the potter is the efficient cause of that pot. The finished product remains with its material, but generally, once the potter's work is done, that efficient cause separates from the object. On our big-scale model, panchabhuutas are upaadaana kaarana and Maya/Iishvara is nimitta kaarana - but both are Brahman only and therefore there is no separation of creator and created. As the five elements themselves arose from Truth, we must conclude that there is some condition of illusion going on. Example often used to illustrate the Grand Illusion is that of the waker and the dreamer. To the dreamer, his world is as real as any in his waking state; mind alone is the creator, sustainer and destroyer of all within the dream world. By positing Maya, Vedanta extends the entirety of srishti to be of a dream-like nature.

For us, the 'dreamers' this world is real! It has many natural laws, for which we have developed specialised sciences to explore them and our relationship with them… but such scientific exploration is not new. What proceeds from here in the text is the ancient wisdom on the physical nature of this Maya-created world.

Seeing Clearly

Hari Om

Each 'Choose-day' we will investigate the process by which we can reassess our activity and interaction with the world of plurality and become more congruent within our personality.

We are reading the small booklet called "Not Too Loose, Not Too tight - Just right!" This is written by Swamini Vimalananda, and gives a very general overview of Vedanta for the beginner, with emphasis on the sattvic, rajasic and tamasic approaches to life. Remember, we are a mixture of all; use this as your mirror.

बुद्धि शक्ति /buddhi-shakti -The Powers of the Mind.

We really have little understanding of how powerful our mind is. It is known that we rarely use it to full capacity! In Vedanta, the essence of teaching is that everything we see and experience is based in mind only. There are certain powers which Maya supplies to 'colour' our mind and divert us, keeping us bonded to our baser existence; here they are presented in terms of the trigunas.

आवरण शक्ति /aavarana shakti - the veiling power.  Tamas has the power to veil or hide that which exists and block our thinking capacity. It either totally incapacitates our discrimination, ("I don't know; I don't understand; I can't think"), or sets it thinking in a wrong direction.  It creates a resistance to any form of physical or mental activity, ("I don't want to know…thinking is too hard!..just let me sleep...")  It is the power of inertia that induces man to want to remain in a state of motion or rest without change.  Aavarana is so strong, that the tamasic mind becomes lazy and does not question the poor state of living.

विक्षेप शक्ति /vikshepa shakti - the projection power. Rajas has the power to project, create, act, interact and change.  It projects even that which is not there a creates illusions which seem very real.  It starts its work of creating false illusions once tamas has done its work of hiding the Truth. The classic illustration for this is the rope and the snake... not knowing the object lying in the dark to be a rope, we mistake it for a snake and get frightened by it. Equally, not really knowing a person, we are still disposed to make assumptions as to his or her goodness. Mankind acts and reacts in the world based on subjective projections, prejudices and the colourings of the mind.  These make him or her agitated and miserable.  Projecting happiness onto an object, we run after it and turn away disappointed when it fails to make us happy. 

विवेक शक्ति /viveka shakti - the discriminative power.  Sattva has the power to discriminate and helps us to see ourselves and the world 'as it is', without aavarana or vikshepa interfering.  Think;

1. On observing closely with a calm mind, one sees the rope, thereby dispelling the false vision of the snake and the fear due to it.
2. Through experience, one understands that no object really makes us happy - or, indeed, unhappy.  It is the mind's projections alone which cause these emotions.

Impediments

Hari Om

Each 'Choose-day' we will investigate the process by which we can reassess our activity and interaction with the world of plurality and become more congruent within our personality.

KINDLE LIFE. We continue exploring points raised by HH Pujya Gurudev Swami Chinmayananda-ji in the publication of this name. Remember, you can purchase, (very economically!), the book from  Chinmaya Mission Publications or if you prefer, the Amazon Link. Thus you can read Gurudev's words directly and bring your own voice to the discussion.

(We have been breaking up Chapter 26 of KL, firstly for length, but also for 'digestion'...mananam! It is hoped that you think deeply upon what you read, making notes and finding levels of inspiration. This is saadhana. To review the chapter so far, click the Choose-day label on right panel.)

By naming all the aspects of nature, resulting in what appears to be a plurality of 'Gods', it is to be understood that there is but one and same God Principle. In fact, individually, each of the named Gods is helpless; they are fully independent. Without creation, there would be no requirement of maintenance or destruction. Without maintenance, creation has built in destruction which does itself have purpose beyond the task done - there can be no re-creation. Only by true 'teamwork' between the three can things exist as they do. What keeps this balance? The One God Principle. Plurality, the idea that each living system of the world and its process can operate independently, is an illusion. There is one governing power.

That nature ( सत्त्व-माया/sattva-maayaa, pure illusion) exists for us at this moment as we wrangle with this philosophy, let us accept. In these times we do have an improved sense of the interconnectedness of everything and it is this which is being called the God Principle. If the reflection of that is found in nature; then next thing to accept is that the reflection of the God Principle also reflects in the realm of activity (rajas) and inactivity (tamas). The ego-self, the individualised sense of separateness, is therefore but a poor reflection of The True Self.

The example which is used often for this is that, just as we can see the sun reflected upon water in a puddles and buckets, none of those 'suns' is the One True Sun.  Equally, each of those reflections can only be as clear and as representative of The Sun as the purity of the water doing the reflecting. The purest clearest and calmest water (sattva) provides the best image. Water which is ruffled and agitated (rajas) by any means causes the reflection to be broken up whilst this is so, but also has the capacity to calm down and become steady again.  Water which has become contaminated with mud or dung (tamas) gives a dull reflection and purifying that water will take some effort.  The tamas quality acts in us in two distinct ways. It produces the mental agitations of  विक्षेप/vikshepa (agitation) and  आवरण/aavarana (veiling).

The veiling power of tamas plays out in three distinct negativities; a) don't know, b) can't understand, 

c) not experienced.  These three negative concepts in us are removed by the three main items of Vedantic practice; a) श्रवणम्/shravanam - listening, b) मननम्/mananam - reflection upon what was heard, c) निदिध्यासन /nididhyaasana - meditation, in attempts to gain the experience.

The first of these three main 'tragedies', is that when left to ourselves, few of us have the capacity to independently observe, analyze and conclude that there is a God Principle behind the ever-changing flux in the phenomenal world.  "I don't know" is the grossest state of aavarana. It is removed by shravanam; either directly from the great masters, or their disciples; or indirectly through reading of the appropriate texts. In taking up shravanam we are removing the first negativity and a subtler one now appears; "I can't understand". This is surmounted by intellectual analysis and reasoning, when the seeker comes to feel that in and through the endless names and forms is running the One Golden Chord of Unity, a sense of oneness, the आत्मन् /aatman (Universal Spirit).

A problem at this stage is that very often, students of philosophy begin to devalue their own intellectual awareness of this changeless Truth, since it is "not experienced" by them. This aavarana manifestation is removed by the process of the prescribed practice of meditation.

Meditation is a process of inner self-discipline by which, through constant practice, the seeker learns the art of keeping their mind at one and the same chosen line of thinking to the strict and severe exclusion of all other dissimilar currents of thought.  Ultimately the saadhaka succeeds in bringing the mind to complete stillness in which, unlike sleep, he has his entire awareness brightly lit up and kindling in his bosom.  At the moment of experiencing the transcendental Bliss and Knowledge, (सविकल्प समाधि /savikalpa samaadhi), the saadhaka comes to chop off the last traces of the aavarana.

From vikshepa arises the unmanifest, subconscious, and from that springs forth the grosser assertion of the manifest - the world of the five elements. The interplay of the elements produces the names and forms, including the senses of knowledge ( ज्ञानेन्द्रियाः/jnaanendriyaH) and the senses of action (कर्मेन्द्रियाः /karmendriyaH), which together constitute the helpless 'traveller of this sea of life', the  संसारिन् /samsaarin. By mistaking/misinterpreting our experience gained through action we build a world around us, separate from The Truth.

With this, we have the 'fall of man'. From being the Eternal, Immortal, All-full Pure Consciousness (नित्य-शुद्ध-मुक्त परमात्मन् /nitya-suddha-mukta paramaatman), due to the play of Maya and like Somadatta's father, we too have come to feel our limitation and live in our unbuilt huts with our unmarried wives and unborn sons.

Vedanta is not a pessimistic philosophy to leave its conclusion with a mere theory of fall. This very theory has been devised to explain the non-existent dream-fall so that the faithful may be shown a way to wake up and realise their own true and eternal nature once more; returning to the OM!

...the conclusion of chapter 26 next week...